When contracts are incomplete, the contracting parties may nd it optimal to renegotiate the terms of trade in the event certain contingencies arise. We study a contracting model with unforeseen contingencies in which the court is an active player. I model labor contracts that are incomplete owing to unforeseen indescribable contingencies, leading to paretoimproving renegotiation and a holdup problem. Incomplete contract theory and contracts between firms. Aug 17, 2017 many writers have suggested that the nature of contracting, firm structure, and even political constitutions cannot be well understood without taking account of the role of unforeseen contingencies. This paper oers an explanation of rationally incomplete contracts where incompleteness refers to unforeseen contingencies. The resulting contracts are often termed incomplete by economists grossman and hart 1986. The inability to describe all relevant contingencies, and make contract terms a. Unforseen contingencies and incomplete contractspower in a theory of the firmthe law and economics of costly contractingincomplete contracts. Incomplete contracting and the structure of collaborative. The incomplete contracts literature often cites indescribable.
Unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts eric maskin harvard university and jean tirole idei, grema q, ceras and mit first version received april 1997. But noone has anticipated a strike among airtraffic controllers. On indescribable contingencies and incomplete contracts, economics working papers 0008, institute for advanced study, school of social science. Seller agrees to manufacture and deliver a specific good to buyer one year.
Tirole 1999 suggests three sources of transaction cost that might be faced in this case and, indeed, more widely. These contingencies have often been called unforeseen by economists tirole 1999, p. Pdf unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts. Courts of law and unforeseen contingencies ing contracts that are written. Concerning the possible meanings of the term unforeseen contingencies. Since its emergence, however, the incomplete contracts litera ture has. However, for all intents and purposes such description is not feasible. Exante, the contracting parties cannot include the risky unforeseen contingencies in the contract they draw up.
The incomplete contracting paradigm was pioneered by sanford j. Unforeseen contingencies, incomplete contracts, finite invariance, fine variability. On indescribable contingencies and incomplete contracts. Pdf definition of incomplete contracts researchgate. In this environment, although agents can compute expected payoffs, they are unable to include in any exante agreement a description of the relevant contingencies that captures even approximately the relevant complexity of the risky environment. Agents enter a relationship with twosided moral hazard in which a commitment to discard parts of the joint resources may be ex ante e. The literature on incomplete contracts see hart 1995 and.
This paper is based on a talk given at the european economic association 2001 meeting in. Incomplete knowledge about unforeseen contingencies is captured by defining some events as fuzzy subsets of the set of unforeseen states of the world. Such events correspond to terms of the language the players were able to use before coming to learn about the unforeseen states. Lorenzo sacconi, incomplete contracts and corporate ethics.
The parties make decisions considering thegains that they can get when. Williamson, o 1985, the economic institutions of capitalism, free press. Ex ante, the contracting parties cannot include the risky unforeseen contingencies inthecontracttheydrawup. Expost the court observes whether an unforeseen contingency occurred, and decides whether to void or uphold the contract. Indescribability and its irrelevance for contractual incompleteness.
Given path dependence, the allocation is suboptimal, with the extent of inefficiency depending upon the degree of incompleteness. Because it doesnt specify what they should do when the cost is 10, so it is not optimal ex post. Such events correspond to terms of the ex ante language used to define. Some previous studies have attempted this exercise, but the framework and results in this paper are different. Many writers have suggested that the nature of contracting, firm structure, and even political constitutions cannot be well understood without taking account of the role of unforeseen contingencies. Risk allocation in contracts 103 future according to qualitative or quantitative factors. Such events correspond to terms of the ex ante language used to define the domain of general abstract principles. We scrutinize the conceptual framework commonly used in the incomplete contract literature. Paradoxically, contracts are both never complete and always complete. Tirole 1999 states that the way they currently stand, unforeseen contingencies are not good motivation for models of incomplete contracts, and he further notes that. Hence, to start with the two parties settle for an incomplete contract. We scrutinize the conceptual framework commonly used in the incomplete contract litera ture.
Jun 25, 2003 incomplete knowledge about unforeseen contingencies is captured by defining some events as fuzzy subsets of the set of unforeseen states of the world. Incomplete contracts, unforeseen contingencies, implementation theory. The incomplete contracts literature, starting from grossman and hart 1986, studies how assigning ownership rights for productive assets affects the efficiency of contractual outcomes. Courts of law and unforeseen contingencies second version. Note that i here eschew the in my view partly semantic distinction between foreseen and unforeseen contingencies by assuming that every. Pdf on jan 1, 2016, susheng wang and others published definition of incomplete. Next, equilibrium contracts are fully characterized. We set forth a contractual environment that displays contingencies that are understood.
Secondbest contracts under moral hazard and adverse selection are not complete since not based on agents type. At date 1, the buyer can make a relationshipspecific investment that increases his expected value from receiving the good. Courts of law and unforeseen contingencies luca anderlini georgetown university leonardo felli london school of economics andrew postlewaite university of pennsylvania we study a contracting model with unforeseen contingencies in which the court is an active player. Unforeseen contingencies, incomplete contracts, finite invariance. Jean tirole, unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts. Recent work on the theory of the firm has argued that incompleteness of contracts that not all future contingencies are covered by the contract is a necessary feature in a. A common justification for the assumption that contracts are not fully contingent on the state of nature is to point out that some aspects of the state may be unforeseen or indescribable to the contracting partners at the time the contract is written. Unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts harvard. Foundations and applications pei, di tsinghua university, beijing, china 31 may 2010 online at mpra paper no. Courts of law and unforeseen contingencies 3 of contingencies that may occur after the signing of a contract, but that cannot be described at the time the parties contract.
This literature usually assumes that contractual incomple. In their seminal contributions, grossman and hart 1986, hart and moore 1990, and hart 1995 argue that in practice, contracts cannot specify what is to be done in every possible contingency. This literature usually assumes that contractual incompleteness is due to the transaction costs of describing or of even foreseeing the possible states of nature in advance. Renegotiation can improve outcomes, but also leads to a holdup problem. Unforeseen contingencies 3 system at any one point in time. In their seminal contributions, grossman and hart 1986, hart and moore 1990, and hart 1995 argue that in. As i explain in more detail below, many definitions are possible, but i will define unforeseen contingencies to be possibilities that the agent does not. Unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts the. Incomplete contracts, incentives and economic power. Instead of providing for all unforeseen contingencies, risksharing and renegotiation variation rules are contained in incomplete contract. Adapting to unforeseen contingencies is the perhaps central problem of economic organization, and the theory of the firm needs to recognize this more fully.
In economic theory, the field of contract theory can be subdivided in the theory of complete contracts and the theory of incomplete contracts the incomplete contracting paradigm was pioneered by sanford j. Firms, incomplete contracts and organizational learning by. Introduction the purpose of this paper is to take stock of the advances and directions for research on the incomplete contracting front. Expost,thecourt observes whether an unforeseen contingency occurred and decides whether to void or uphold the contract.
I examine the theoretical foundations underlying the incomplete contracts literature. However, many contingencies are unforeseen at the time of contracting. Courts of law and unforeseen contingencies 3 contingencies, and make contract terms a function of them, a ects agents incentives. These are contingencies that are understood by economic agents their consequences and probabilities are known but are such that every description of such events necessarily leaves out relevant features that have a nonnegligible impact on the parties expected utilities. Unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts, the. Unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts eric maskin. If the contract is voided by the court, the parties can renegotiate a new agreement expost. As i explain in more detail below, many definitions are possible, but i will define unforeseen contingencies to be possibilities that the agent. A in paris is supposed to deliver equipment to b in oslo. I model labor contracts that are incomplete owing to unforeseenindescribable contingencies, leading to paretoimproving renegotiation and a holdup problem. The inability to describe all relevant contingencies, and make contract terms a function of them, a. It is impossibleto describesuch unforeseen contingencies in acontract,thus a contract cannot help being an incompletecontract. On indescribable contingencies and incomplete contracts, economics working papers 0008. Williamson, o 1975, markets and hierarchies, free press.
Contracts that condition on every possible state of the world. Eric maskin institute for advanced study and princeton university september 2001 jel classi. Formal models of how firms write contracts for exchange have contemplated the significance of many factors that may cause contracts to be incomplete. The holdup problem plays a central role in the recent literature on incomplete contracts and the modern theory of the firm. It is shown that there are equilibria where the insurer strategically o ers incomplete contracts. The resulting contracts are often termed incomplete.
It is clear that contingencies that are unforeseen in the sense intuitively sketched out above cannot possibly be included in any exante contractual agreement that the agents may contemplate. The paper models contracts that are incomplete owing to the presence of unforeseenindescribable contingencies, which opens up the possibility of renegotiation. When contracts are incomplete, the contracting parties may nd it optimal to renegotiate the terms of trade in. Because uncertainty exacerbates the transaction hazard to market governance posed by asset specificity williamson, 1985. Maskin e, tirole j 1999 unforeseen contingencies and incomplete contracts. Incomplete contracts, the holdup problem, and asymmetric. Incomplete contract and verifiability kier, kyoto university. Unforeseen contingencies a nd incomplete contract s.
613 565 1403 153 899 154 287 611 768 426 582 19 270 1173 734 1138 132 144 1087 1525 183 913 1398 1400 803 413 34 577 1233 783 854 1147 1046 1144 1131